Maximum Split of Positive Even Integers
MedPrompt
You are given an integer finalSum. Split it into a sum of a maximum number of unique positive even integers.
- For example, given
finalSum = 12, the following splits are valid (unique positive even integers summing up tofinalSum):(12),(2 + 10),(2 + 4 + 6), and(4 + 8). Among them,(2 + 4 + 6)contains the maximum number of integers. Note thatfinalSumcannot be split into(2 + 2 + 4 + 4)as all the numbers should be unique.
Return a list of integers that represent a valid split containing a maximum number of integers. If no valid split exists for finalSum, return an empty list. You may return the integers in any order.
Example 1:
(12)Example 2:
Input: finalSum = 7
Output: []
Explanation: There are no valid splits for the given finalSum.
Thus, we return an empty array.Example 3:
(2 + 26)
Constraints:
1 <= finalSum <= 1010
Approaches
2 approaches with complexity analysis and trade-offs.
This approach attempts to find the solution by exploring all possible combinations of unique positive even integers that sum up to finalSum. It uses a recursive function to build potential splits. At each step, the function decides which even number to add next and recurses with the remaining sum. This brute-force method will eventually find the split with the maximum number of elements by checking every valid partition.
Algorithm
- Handle the base case: if
finalSumis odd, it's impossible to form it from even numbers, so return an empty list. - Use a recursive backtracking function, say
solve(remainingSum, startEvenNum, currentSplit), to explore all possibilities. remainingSum: The target sum left to achieve.startEvenNum: The next smallest even number we can consider adding to ensure uniqueness.currentSplit: The list of numbers forming the current partial solution.- Base Case: If
remainingSumis 0, a valid split has been found. Compare its size with the maximum size found so far and update the global result if it's larger. - Recursive Step: For each even number
istarting fromstartEvenNumup toremainingSum: a. AdditocurrentSplit. b. Make a recursive call:solve(remainingSum - i, i + 2, currentSplit). c. Backtrack by removingifromcurrentSplitto explore other branches. - This process explores all possible partitions into unique even numbers, and we keep the one with the most elements.
Walkthrough
The backtracking algorithm systematically generates all partitions of finalSum into unique, positive, even integers. We define a recursive helper function that takes the remaining sum to be made, the starting even number to consider (to enforce uniqueness and order), and the current list of numbers in the split.
The function has two main cases:
- Base Case: If the remaining sum is zero, it means we've successfully found a valid split. We then check if this new split has more numbers than the best one we've found so far. If it does, we update our answer.
- Recursive Step: We iterate through all possible even numbers
ithat can be added (i.e.,i <= remainingSum). For eachi, we add it to our current split and make a recursive call for the new remaining sum (remainingSum - i). To ensure the numbers are unique, the next recursive call can only use even numbers greater thani. After the recursive call returns, we backtrack by removingito explore other possibilities.
While correct in theory, this approach is computationally expensive as the number of partitions can grow exponentially with finalSum.
// NOTE: This is a conceptual implementation and will Time Limit Exceed.class Solution { List<Long> maxSplit = new ArrayList<>(); public List<Long> maximumEvenSplit(long finalSum) { if (finalSum % 2 != 0) { return new ArrayList<>(); } find(finalSum, 2L, new ArrayList<>()); return maxSplit; } private void find(long target, long startNum, List<Long> currentSplit) { if (target == 0) { if (currentSplit.size() > maxSplit.size()) { maxSplit = new ArrayList<>(currentSplit); } return; } if (target < startNum) { return; } // Explore all possible next numbers for (long i = startNum; i <= target; i += 2) { currentSplit.add(i); find(target - i, i + 2, currentSplit); currentSplit.remove(currentSplit.size() - 1); // Backtrack } }}Complexity
Time
O(2^N) or higher (exponential)
Space
O(sqrt(finalSum))
Trade-offs
Pros
It's a straightforward brute-force method that is guaranteed to find the optimal solution if given enough time.
Cons
Extremely inefficient due to its exponential time complexity.
Will result in a 'Time Limit Exceeded' (TLE) error for the given constraints.
The recursion depth can be large, potentially leading to a stack overflow for very large
finalSum, although the number of elements is limited bysqrt(finalSum).
A greedy approach is the most efficient way to solve this problem. The core idea is that to maximize the number of elements in the sum, we should use the smallest possible unique positive even integers. We can iteratively build our split by adding 2, 4, 6, 8, and so on, until we can no longer add the next even number without exceeding finalSum. The final remaining amount is then consolidated into the largest number in our split to maintain the sum and uniqueness.
Algorithm
- First, check if
finalSumis odd. If so, a split is impossible, so return an empty list. - Initialize an empty list
resultto store the integers. - Initialize a variable
currentEvento 2, representing the smallest positive even integer. - Initialize
remainingSumtofinalSum. - Loop as long as the next number to add (
currentEven) is less than or equal to theremainingSum. a. AddcurrentEvento theresultlist. b. SubtractcurrentEvenfromremainingSum. c. IncrementcurrentEvenby 2 to get the next unique even number. - After the loop terminates, the
remainingSumwill be a positive even integer that was too small to be the next term in the sequence (i.e.,remainingSum < currentEven). - To ensure the total sum is correct and all numbers are unique, add this
remainingSumto the last (and largest) number already in theresultlist. - Return the
resultlist.
Walkthrough
This method is based on a greedy strategy. We start by checking if finalSum is even. If not, we return an empty list as a sum of even numbers cannot be odd.
To get the maximum number of terms, we should pick the smallest unique positive even numbers: 2, 4, 6, ... We iteratively add these numbers to a list and subtract them from a running remainingSum (initialized to finalSum).
We continue this process as long as the next even number to be added is not greater than the remainingSum. When the loop terminates, the remainingSum will hold the leftover amount. This leftover amount is guaranteed to be even. Because it was not large enough to form a new unique even number in our sequence, we simply add it to the last number we placed in our list. This ensures the sum is correct, all numbers are positive and even, and because we add it to the largest element, uniqueness is preserved.
For example, if finalSum = 28:
- Add 2,
remainingSum= 26. List:[2] - Add 4,
remainingSum= 22. List:[2, 4] - Add 6,
remainingSum= 16. List:[2, 4, 6] - Add 8,
remainingSum= 8. List:[2, 4, 6, 8] - Next even number is 10, which is greater than
remainingSum(8). Stop. - The leftover is 8. Add it to the last element (8). The last element becomes
8 + 8 = 16. - Final list:
[2, 4, 6, 16]. Sum = 28. All unique, positive, even.
import java.util.ArrayList;import java.util.List; class Solution { public List<Long> maximumEvenSplit(long finalSum) { // If finalSum is odd, it's impossible to split it into even integers. if (finalSum % 2 != 0) { return new ArrayList<>(); } List<Long> result = new ArrayList<>(); long currentEven = 2; long remainingSum = finalSum; // Greedily take the smallest unique even numbers as long as the remainder // is large enough to accommodate the current number. while (currentEven <= remainingSum) { result.add(currentEven); remainingSum -= currentEven; currentEven += 2; } // The remainingSum is what's left. Since we couldn't form a new unique // even number with it, we add it to the largest number we've already added // to maintain the total sum and uniqueness. if (remainingSum > 0) { long lastElement = result.remove(result.size() - 1); result.add(lastElement + remainingSum); } return result; }}Complexity
Time
O(sqrt(finalSum)) - The `while` loop iterates `k` times, where the sum of the first `k` even numbers (`~k^2`) is on the order of `finalSum`.
Space
O(sqrt(finalSum)) - to store the resulting list of numbers. The number of elements `k` in the list is such that `k^2` is approximately `finalSum`.
Trade-offs
Pros
Highly efficient with a time complexity of O(sqrt(finalSum)).
Simple to implement and understand.
Guaranteed to produce a correct result with the maximum number of integers.
Cons
The correctness of the greedy choice is not immediately obvious without a proof or strong intuition.
Solutions
Solution
public class Solution { public IList < long > MaximumEvenSplit(long finalSum) { IList < long > ans = new List < long > (); if (finalSum % 2 == 1) { return ans; } for (long i = 2; i <= finalSum; i += 2) { ans.Add(i); finalSum -= i; } ans[ans.Count - 1] += finalSum; return ans; }}class Solution {public List<Long> maximumEvenSplit(long finalSum) { List<Long> ans = new ArrayList<>(); if (finalSum % 2 == 1) { return ans; } for (long i = 2; i <= finalSum; i += 2) { ans.add(i); finalSum -= i; } ans.add(ans.remove(ans.size() - 1) + finalSum); return ans; }}class Solution {public: vector<long long> maximumEvenSplit(long long finalSum) { vector<long long> ans; if (finalSum % 2) return ans; for (long long i = 2; i <= finalSum; i += 2) { ans.push_back(i); finalSum -= i; } ans.back() += finalSum; return ans; }};class Solution: def maximumEvenSplit(self, finalSum: int) -> List[int]: if finalSum % 2: return [] i = 2 ans = [] while i <= finalSum: ans . append(i) finalSum -= i i += 2 ans[- 1] += finalSum return ansVideo walkthrough
Newsletter
One sharp idea, every week
System design and interview prep — short enough to finish.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Practice
Same difficulty — related problems to reinforce the pattern.